House Votes to Sue OPEC

by Sean Hackbarth

Suing foreigners gets you no political enemies. Suing Arab foreigners who pump high-priced oil out of the ground that becomes high-priced gasoline will get you applause. The House of Representatives passed a bill giving the government the power to sue OPEC:

[Rep. John] Conyers accused the OPEC engaging in a “price fixing conspiracy” that has “unfairly driven up the price” of crude oil and, in turn gasoline.

His measure would change antitrust laws so that the Justice Department can sue OPEC member countries for price-fixing, and would remove the immunity given a sovereign state against such lawsuits.

Conyers’ use of the word “conspiracy” misses the mark because the whole point of forming a cartel is to fix prices. There’s no conspiracy since OPEC is out in the open about limiting production to support prices.

The Russian foreign ministry declared the bill a violation of international law. That’s funny since President Bush’s Democratic Congressional critics complain he’s flaunted international law.

This bill is simply symbolism over substance. Even if the bill passed and the Bush administration went after OPEC countries in court enforcing any ruling against an OPEC would boomerang on the U.S. causing even higher gas prices. Such grand thinking escaped 345 Congressmen because this bill gives them an example of doing something about high gas prices even if it ignores the reality of the U.S. gas market.

“House Passes Bill to Sue OPEC, Lower Gas Prices”

UPDATE: Commenter Clarendon points out every single member of the Wisconsin delegation voted for this piece of junk. That includes conservatives James Sensenbrenner and Paul Ryan. They have some explaining to do.

Save and Share:
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • email
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Digg
  • Diigo

3 Responses to “House Votes to Sue OPEC”


What else did you expect from a mindset that states that the “proper” way to lower prices on a commodity is to regulate the domestic production of said commodity to death and then increase government’s take from the sale of said commodity?


Well, make some phone calls. The entire Wisconsin Congressional Delegation voted for this joke.


[...] Step 2 (with a hat tip to Sean Hackbarth) – Sue OPEC, as most of the House, including the entire Wisconsin delegation voted to do yesterday. The only way to get any sort of judgement against OPEC (side note; the “C” stands for “Cartel”) is to sue domestically because the international courts the Left is so fond of would properly laugh us out of there, and the only way to enforce that judgement is to invade and occupy each and every member of OPEC (not that I would necessarily be against that). Talk about your “blood for oil”. [...]

Leave a Reply

You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>