Eloquent McCain

by Sean Hackbarth

After all cots were slept on, pizza eaten, toothbrushes given, the Senate all-nighter ended the way it started. Democrats failed to get cloture on the Levin-Reed amendment that would force President Bush to begin recalling troops from Iraq in 120 days.

What we did get out of all the flapping of lips was a passionate speech by Sen. John McCain. Here’s an especially important portion dealing with public opinion and the role of our representatives:

I have also listened to my colleagues on the other side repeatedly remind us that the American people have spoken in the last election. They have demanded we withdraw from Iraq, and it is our responsibility to do, as quickly as possible, what they have bid us to do. But is that our primary responsibility? Really, Mr. President, is that how we construe our role: to follow without question popular opinion even if we believe it to be in error, and likely to endanger the security of the country we have sworn to defend? Surely, we must be responsive to the people who have elected us to office, and who, if it is their wish, will remove us when they become unsatisfied with our failure to heed their demands. I understand that, of course. And I understand why so many Americans have become sick and tired of this war, given the many, many mistakes made by civilian and military leaders in its prosecution. I, too, have been made sick at heart by these mistakes and the terrible price we have paid for them. But I cannot react to these mistakes by embracing a course of action that I know will be an even greater mistake, a mistake of colossal historical proportions, which will — and I am as sure of this as I am of anything – seriously endanger the people I represent and the country I have served all my adult life. I have many responsibilities to the people of Arizona, and to all Americans. I take them all seriously, Mr. President, or try to. But I have one responsibility that outweighs all the others – and that is to do everything in my power, to use whatever meager talents I posses, and every resource God has granted me to protect the security of this great and good nation from all enemies foreign and domestic. And that I intend to do, Mr. President, even if I must stand athwart popular opinion. I will explain my reasons to the American people. I will attempt to convince as many of my countrymen as I can that we must show even greater patience, though our patience is nearly exhausted, and that as long as there is a prospect for not losing this war, then we must not choose to lose it. That is how I construe my responsibility to my constituency and my country. That is how I construed it yesterday. It is how I construe it today. And it is how I will construe it tomorrow. I do not know how I could choose any other course.

President Bush, that’s how you communicate to a tired, frustrated public.

And in what should scare Senators of both parties who are cranky from working so long with little sleep Miles Mogulescu at The Huffington Post wants more all-nighters, not just for Iraq, but for Medicare and any of the Left’s favorite bills.

This could catch on with the netroots. Capitol Hill staff better keep the cots handy.

Save and Share: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • del.icio.us
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Digg
  • NewsVine
  • Furl
  • YahooMyWeb
  • Fark

5 Responses to “Eloquent McCain”

1

I think it is an eloquent defense of why he thinks a legislator can’t always simply follow the polls. However, it isn’t an actual defense of his views on Iraq.

2

No, it isn’t any defense of the war. It did turn on the Burkean in me.

Such an approach is what I most admire about President Bush. The Iraq War is unpopular yet he continues. He took on Social Security and immigration, not for popularity, but because he thinks both were in the best interests. It has been a wonderful contrast to poll-obsessed Clinton administration.

3

The filibuster that dare not speak its name!

Why is it that when Republicans do it, conservatives suddenly forget the “f-word”? Why did Republicans block an up-or-down vote?

4

Why did Republicans block an up-or-down vote?

Did you read McCain’s speech?

5

I must confess, I am not all the inclined to get rev’d up by the notion that elected officials should regularly ignore the populace. It violates, to me, key elements of democracy. While I concur that politicians should not govern by polls and I agree that clearly there are times with those in government have more information on a given topic than the population, the notion that we cede all decision-making to elected officials during their time in office is a problematic one, I would argue.

At a minimum the issue raises important questions about how representative democracy ought to work.

Leave a Reply




You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>